Clarification (Updated)
A while back I wrote an essay, “Too Young to Publish”, which has been much linked to and discussed around the traps. Very gratifying that people have found it useful and thought provoking, cause, you know, that’s why I write these things. A few people, however, seem to have read me as saying that if you’re young you can’t be talented and shouldn’t be published.
Not no way never.
I’m glad Sonya Hartnett, S. E. Hinton and this really great fantasy writer whose name I’ve completely forgotten (update: Joyce Ballou Gregorian) who died very young (update: She was 21 when her first book pub’d and 44 when she died) after only two or three fab books (whose titles likewise are escaping me—update: The Broken Citadel 1975, Castledown 1977 and The Great Wheel 1987) published when they did. They were well and truly good enough.
The essay was addressed to the impatient, overly-convinced-of-her-own-genius, fifteen-year-old me. Even though I wouldn’t have listened and would have told the current me to bugger off. I was inspired to write it by teenage writers who wrote asking me about the age thing, and one of them kinda reminded me of me at that age (only less obnoxious).
Everything I said applies to a beginning writer of any age. No matter how old you are when you start writing, making being published your first priority and being driven into a deep, dark depression when you’re not is a waste of time. Improving your craft, learning to be a writer, a really good writer, is the thing. There are writers in their sixties who still don’t get this and writers in their teens who are all over it.
Posted by Justine at 13:12, 31 August 2005 under Bloggery, Words & Language, Writing life | 4 Comments »

- 1930s NYC novel
- Admin
- Basketball
- Battle of the Sexes in Science Fiction
- Best of Blog
- Bloggery
- Book challenges
- Book tour
- Cons & Other Gatherings
- Cricket
- Daughters of Earth
- Excuses
- Fan art
- Fans & readers
- Fashion
- Feminism
- First Kiss
- Food
- Frippery
- Garden
- Guest post
- How To Ditch Your Fairy
- Ideas
- Ironical (This is Writ)
- Last Day of the Year
- Liar
- Liquids
- Listening
- Love is Hell
- Magic or Madness trilogy
- Manga
- Mangosteens
- Musings
- New York City/USA
- Praising
- Publishing business
- RSI
- Ranting
- Reading
- Research
- Science
- Scott's books
- Search Terms
- Sport
- State of the World
- Sydney/Australia
- Team Human
- Titles & names
- Toilets
- Tour de France
- Travelling
- Unicorns
- Vainglory
- Viewing
- What's your fairy?
- Whingeing
- Words & Language
- Writing goals & milestones
- Writing life
- Writing process
- Young Adult literature
- Zombies
- Zombies v Unicorns
Categories
Archives
- @postteen I didn't say no metaphors. Just no similes. I ain't no Calvinist! Pass me the booze. # 2 hours ago
- @postteen Wait. You're citing Hemingway as an example of *good* writing? Er, I have no response to such madness. #death2similes # 2 hours ago
- I'm offended. Battling similes is MUCH crazier. RT: @thebravetart that's as crazy as attacking the Oxford comma @Gwenda @christopherrowe # 2 hours ago
Recent Comments
- Lorin on You don’t have to read my books
- Mandi on Writing FAQ
- L.H. on A Story What I Wrote in My Late Teens! Avert Thine Eyes! Run for the Hills!
- Madeleine Robins on You don’t have to read my books
- Justine on You don’t have to read my books
- Rachel Neumeier on You don’t have to read my books
- Justine on You don’t have to read my books
- Maria (BearMountainBooks) on You don’t have to read my books
- Sam X on You don’t have to read my books
- Ted Lemon on You don’t have to read my books
- Adalat on FAQ
- Justine on Team Human Fanart
- emily on Team Human Fanart
- Liana on Team Human Fanart
- Justine on Team Human Fanart
Recent Posts
- Cassandra Clare on the Myth that Authors Automatically Condone What We Depict
- You don’t have to read my books
- Team Human Fanart
- A Story What I Wrote in My Late Teens! Avert Thine Eyes! Run for the Hills!
- I’ll Know I’ve Made it as a Writer When . . .
- Why I Cannot Write a Novel With Voice Recognition Software (Updated x 3)
- Writing Goals Reduxing the Redux
- Last Day of 2011 (Updated)
- My Books of Electrons!
- Because No One Should Suffer Alone
- Sekrit Project Revealed!
- Writing Liar with Scrivener
- Feeling Good
- The Misery of Voice Recognition Software
- Photo Request
Best of Blog
- Liar Spoiler Thread (updated)
- January is writing advice month (sticky post) Updated
- How I finished my first novel
- Types of crazy writers
- How to rewrite
- Getting paid, or, don’t quit your day job
- How to write a novel*
- A Writer’s Job (Updated)
- Too Young to Publish
- Average First Novel Advances
- A Beginner’s Guide to Cricket
- Being Dumped is Much Much Worse



tobias s buckell Says:
I didn’t think you were saying that, I was disagreeing with Sartorias
August 31st, 2005 at 3:51 PM
2. Justine Says:
I know that. But other people had misinterpreted me in that way and your post reminded me I’ve been wanting to set ‘em straight.
August 31st, 2005 at 3:57 PM
tobias s buckell Says:
gotcha!
August 31st, 2005 at 4:56 PM
Elizabeth Genco Says:
Dang — now I want to know who that really great, really young fantasy writer is!
September 3rd, 2005 at 12:45 PM