Justine Larbalestier

reading, writing, eating, drinking, sport

«

»

This is just to say . . .

That spending any amount of time judging the ethical, moral or ideological purity of your allies in struggles to cause change derails those very efforts. Let’s focus on the struggle itself, shall we? And not get bogged down kneecapping people on the same side. It never ends well.

This applies to pretty much everything from baking a cake, to running a bookclub, a government or fomenting revolution.

Posted by Justine at 21:45, 27 January 2010 under State of the World | 13 Comments »

Comments

  1. Christopher Says:

    I have visited
    my ally
    with an
    icepick

    Educate, agitate, organize, J.

    xxx
    cvr

    January 27th, 2010 at 10:24 pm

  2. Lauren Says:

    Good point… definate issue in our bookclub/ even in our church too! thnx justine!

    January 27th, 2010 at 10:24 pm

  3. 3. Justine Says:

    Christopher: So pleased my lame ref to a famous USian poem was recognised. See? I has spent so much time in your land that I now reference poems I’d never heard of before I went there.

    Lauren: Sadly it is an issue everywhere. If you find yourself thinking why am I arguing about this? What does it have to do with improving things? Then you know there’s ally icepicking going on.

    January 27th, 2010 at 11:20 pm

  4. angharad Says:

    I couldn’t say this. I’m glad you did. Thank you.

    January 28th, 2010 at 12:17 am

  5. HeatherL Says:

    But isn’t there a limit to what you should, or can, ignore? How much misbehavior can you put up with from someone on your side before they start bringing you down with them (morally or otherwise)? Don’t you have to sometimes stop and analyze to make sure everyone is within reasonable bounds?

    I remember that poem too- makinglight has a really cute post parodying it somewhere in their archives, but I am too lazy to google for the link right now. Recommend it though.

    January 28th, 2010 at 12:24 am

  6. 6. Justine Says:

    Angharad: Tee. Anyone can talk this obliquely.

    HeatherL: I guess you have to start wondering about whether they’re an ally then.

    But what I’m talking about are the people for whom “purity” (of whatever kind) is more imporant than the actual struggle. After awhile you start to realise that maybe that’s all they care about, bullying other people into their idea of proper behaviour.

    Hmm, I guess that winds up at the same place, doesn’t it? Wondering whether they’re really allies.

    January 28th, 2010 at 1:01 am

  7. angharad Says:

    True, but very few of us can say something like this and have it be a productive comment. Were I to pop in at a few threads and say just the same thing it would only be MORE DERAILING. Which is very frustrating. All I can do is conclude that someone is wrong on the internet and quietly withdraw even when I know that people retreating to safe spaces is movement in exactly the wrong direction.

    However, I think, just for this moment, when you say something like this it IS constructive. I guess from some of the things you’ve said that being at the center of the shit storm over the Liar cover was no fun at all, but I think it gives you the leg to stand on that you need in order to be heard when allies are bringing out the icepicks.

    For most of us, the struggle really is the thing, but we can all get derailed when we’re frustrated and any one of us can drift into being bullies and thought police.

    January 28th, 2010 at 1:28 am

  8. angharad Says:

    Or for that matter sanctimonious like whoa. Sorry about that.

    January 28th, 2010 at 1:31 am

  9. 9. Justine Says:

    Angharad: I did mean this post to apply far more widely than that. I was thinking also of political events here in Australia and the US and elsewhere.

    But as for the cover thing. I’m so thrilled to see how quickly Little, Brown has responded and to see the groups that have sprung up to keep a vigilant eye out for other cases of white washing. The work of people like Ari and Susan has been very inspiring.

    I hope, as many of us do, that all of this will go even further. That these recent protests will lead to the publication of more books by and about people of colour. And more poc employed within publishing too.

    January 28th, 2010 at 2:00 am

  10. Brendan Podger Says:

    Say your piece once. If people don’t understand what you are trying to say(even if they think you are wrong), move on. They will never get it.

    January 28th, 2010 at 2:00 am

  11. Mary Arrrr Says:

    The most dangerous delusion is the belief that things can’t get any worse.

    January 28th, 2010 at 12:02 pm

  12. angharad Says:

    I want so much to believe that where LIAR might have been a one-off, MUG might signal real change for covers at least. That’s why I hate it so much to see people derailed by UR doin it Wrong posts. But it’s true that it’s easy to be disappointed by people online. It’s not just that people get snarkier, I think I get over-sensitive and think, hey, are you really my ally? And of course, that wondering glance at the people in the lines to your left and to your right happens in *many* venues.

    January 28th, 2010 at 12:28 pm

  13. JojoLindsey Says:

    This is awesome. Hey do you think you guys could look at my blog and give me some comments?? http://www.jojolindsey.wordpress.com Liar was AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!

    January 28th, 2010 at 9:42 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

As soon as I can I set free all comments trapped in moderation. Keep in mind, though, you might be commenting in the USA while I am asleep in Sydney. Or I might be asleep in NYC while you are commenting in Australia.

Subscribe to this post's comments by RSS

Spam filters ate your comment? Let me know and I will rescue it.

    Categories

    Archives

    RSS Feed

    Subscribe

<-- -->