Quick Note on Yesterday’s Post
I’m very sorry that some reviewers of YA were upset or worried by yesterday’s post. I truly was not talking about you. If you’re reading my blog. odds are you know and care about the genre, which is something the people who write those kinds of reviews are often lacking—especially the knowledge.
There are two groups who are writing the kinds of reviews I was mocking:
- Reviewers for trade mags/journals/newspaper who are being asked to review outside their area of expertise
- Amateur reviewers whose gateway drug to YA was Twilight
The vast majority of specialist kidlit bloggers and trade reviewers are mad keen lovers of the genre who are knowledgeable about its history and don’t make idiotic mistakes like accusing L. J. Smith of ripping off Stephenie Meyer. My post was not aimed at any of you. The kidlit bloggers and reviewers do a wonderful job of keeping people like me informed about our genre and what books we should be reading.
Keep up the good work!
Posted by Justine at 17:33, 3 December 2009 under Young Adult literature | 2 Comments »
Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a Reply
Spam filters ate your comment? Let me know and I will rescue it.

- 1930s NYC novel
- Admin
- Basketball
- Battle of the Sexes in Science Fiction
- Best of Blog
- Bloggery
- Book challenges
- Book tour
- Cons & Other Gatherings
- Cricket
- Daughters of Earth
- Excuses
- Fans & readers
- Fashion
- Feminism
- First Kiss
- Food
- Frippery
- Garden
- Guest post
- How To Ditch Your Fairy
- Ideas
- Last Day of the Year
- Liar
- Liquids
- Listening
- Love is Hell
- Magic or Madness trilogy
- Manga
- Mangosteens
- Musings
- New York City/USA
- Praising
- Publishing business
- Ranting
- Reading
- Research
- Science
- Scott's books
- Search Terms
- Sport
- State of the World
- Sydney/Australia
- Titles & names
- Toilets
- Tour de France
- Travelling
- Unicorns
- Vainglory
- Viewing
- What's your fairy?
- Whingeing
- Words & Language
- Writing goals & milestones
- Writing life
- Writing process
- Young Adult literature
- Zombies
- Zombies v Unicorns
Categories
Archives
Subscribe
- Thanks, @SairzBillington. It was an honour to win the FAW Christina Stead. I'm dead chuffed. Congrats to you on your win! # 8 hours ago
- For charity--read @maureenjohnson's post: http://tinyurl.com/acciomj # 2010/03/20
- The fabulous @meg_r blogs today about reading quirks: http://wp.me/peDKA-2bG Mine is prolly my obsessive spoiler avoidance. Tell her yours! # 2010/03/18
Recent Comments
- Tricia Sullivan on Liar Spoiler Thread (updated)
- celsie on Guest Post: Megan Reid on Being a Bad Reader
- Nelle on Liar Spoiler Thread (updated)
- Justine on FAQ
- Lisa on FAQ
- Justine on FAQ
- Justine on FAQ
- Justine on FAQ
- Justine on Writing FAQ
- rockinlibrarian on Liar Spoiler Thread (updated)
- Linden on Guest Post: Megan Reid on Being a Bad Reader
- Julia Rios on Guest Post: Megan Reid on Being a Bad Reader
- Justine on Guest Post: Alaya Johnson: “What My Dad Said”
- Alyson Greene on Guest Post: Megan Reid on Being a Bad Reader
- Mel on Guest Post: Alaya Johnson: “What My Dad Said”
Recent Posts
- Guest Post: Megan Reid on Being a Bad Reader
- Guest Post: Kristin Cashore on the Flying Trapeze
- Guest Post: Courtney Milan on Lying
- How to Get Published? Don’t Ask Me
- What Four Hours Means + Answering Some Quessies
- Guest Post: Alaya Johnson: “What My Dad Said”
- Guest Post: Melina Marchetta on Personal Taste
- Guest Post: Claire Light on How to Put Together a Story
- Guest Post: Diana Peterfreund on Inspiration
- Nonsensical Jibber-Jabber: the Joy of One-Star Reviews
- Request for Readers who Have the US Edition of Liar (updated x 2)
- Mangosteen season
- Songs of Girls Who Don’t Want to Get Married (Right Now) + Thanks
- Guest Post: David Levithan on Why He Writes
- Guest Post: Ron Bradfield Jnr: “It’s All English to Me”
Best of Blog
- Liar Spoiler Thread (updated)
- January is writing advice month (sticky post) Updated
- How I finished my first novel
- Types of crazy writers
- How to rewrite
- Getting paid, or, don’t quit your day job
- How to write a novel*
- A Writer’s Job (Updated)
- Too Young to Publish
- Average First Novel Advances
- A Beginner’s Guide to Cricket
- Being Dumped is Much Much Worse


Team Toshi Banana Says:
There are definitely plenty of good YA reviewers! My pet peeve is when a teen reviews a book and says, “I didn’t really like it, it wasn’t as good as Twilight”. I mean, liking Twilight is one thing, it’s a good book. But saying you don’t like a book because it’s not as good as Twilight… well, there are great books out there that have nothing in common with Twilight! When one book is all you compare anything to, it gets annoying to the reader.
December 3rd, 2009 at 8:54 pm
Team Toshi Banana Says:
Oh, and also, I just finished How to Ditch Your Fairy and I loved it! I can’t wait to read Liar! It sounds really good!
December 3rd, 2009 at 8:59 pm